
TL;DR
You can have plenty of people around you and still feel alone. The loneliness comes when nobody knows how challenging work has been for the last two months, or how anxious you are about being laid off. For many men, the habit of saying “all good” started early. As boys they learned that their place in the family came from keeping things together, and that they had to handle their worries and concerns.
Work and mates may have rewarded that habit for years, so most men have never had a reason to question it. In adult life, the habit often shows up as a belief that telling a mate would make you a burden. You may also worry that if you are honest about what you’re really feeling, people will think less of you.
Being honest about what you feel is something many men have to relearn, and it takes courage. Honesty comes more easily with a mate you trust, and one honest sentence is a practical place to start.
The Drive Home After “All Good”
You’re driving home after footy, and a few minutes ago a mate asked how you were going. You said “all good” before you’d thought about it. Work has been challenging for the last two months, and you’re anxious about being laid off. You haven’t spoken about it to anyone, and on the drive home you realise you aren’t sure who you would speak to.
You have plenty of people around you, from the footy club to your mates from work. You talk to some of them most days, about the game and the job. When one of them had a bad patch last year, you were the one who rang him and let him talk it through. When the bad patch is your own, you keep it to yourself. For many men, that habit started as boys and teenagers.
Why You Feel Alone When You Have People Around You
Most men in this position have an explanation ready. He tells himself that blokes don’t really talk about this stuff, that everyone has enough on, and that it’s just been a rough couple of months. Each of those can be partly true.
Friendships built around footy and work often stay on footy and work. Time is short, and there is always a game or a job to talk about. These friendships are important in a man’s life, even when the talk stays on the surface. They give him company and people who are glad to see him each week. Plenty of these friendships work well for men as they are.
These reasons explain why the talk stays light with some mates. Two things are still unexplained. One is why a man gives “all good” to every mate, including those he’s known for a long time. The other is why he feels alone in a room full of people who like him.
Why do I feel alone even with friends?
Many men who feel this way have good friends. You feel alone because none of them knows what you’re dealing with. Every mate gets “all good”, so nobody knows how challenging work has been or that you’re anxious about being laid off. You can be surrounded by people and still deal with that worry alone.
What It Costs When Nobody Knows What You’re Dealing With
When nobody knows what a man is dealing with at work, he has nobody to talk it over with or support him. He handles the fear of being laid off on his own, at his desk and in the car, and sometimes at two in the morning. His mates would probably want to know. They can’t support him through something he keeps to himself.
The cost builds over years. A man can have a full calendar and a phone full of contacts and still feel that nobody knows him. At a fortieth, he spends three hours talking about footy tipping and the new ute, then drives home knowing nobody there knows about his job.
The friends at that fortieth like him, and they like the man who always has things handled. Every friend there has met only that version of him, because he has shown them nothing else. Their friendliness is real, and he enjoys the night. Nobody asks how he is really going, because as far as they can tell, he is fine.
The sociologist Robert Weiss (1973) described two kinds of loneliness. Social loneliness comes from having too few people around you. Emotional loneliness comes from having nobody you are truly close to. The man at the fortieth has plenty of people, and he is lonely in the second way.
Keeping the talk on surface issues protects his place as the one who copes. After enough nights like that fortieth, he can start to believe nobody would understand, and “all good” becomes the easier thing to say each time.
When Your Partner Is the Only One Who Knows
Many men talk to their partner about what is going on, and to nobody else. Talking to your partner matters, and having your partner as the only person you tell brings two problems.
The first problem is that one person hears everything. Your partner hears every worry while dealing with their own, and may have little left to give when things are hard for them too. When the problem is partly about home, you have nobody else to talk it through with.
The second problem shows if the relationship ends. Many men find their partner was the only person who knew how they were really going. Their friendships never went past footy and work. They lose the relationship and the only person they talked to at the same time.
Letting one mate know how you’re really going is easier to start while your relationship is going well. Starting now gives that friendship time to grow, no matter what happens at home.
Where Keeping Things Together Often Starts
For many men like this, the habit of saying “all good” goes back to boyhood. As a boy or a teenager, he may have learned that his place in the family came from keeping things together. How he learned it differs from family to family.
Some boys step in without being asked. Perhaps his father worked away, or his mother had more than she could manage, and he saw what was needed and did it. Other boys are told what is expected of them. The eldest son hears that he is the man of the house now, or that he has to be strong for his mother. In some families, a boy who complained or cried was told to toughen up, so he stopped bringing his worries to anyone. Some boys copy what they see in a father who never said how he was really doing.
Whichever way it happened, his own worries became something he dealt with on his own.
How the Habit Becomes Part of Who He Is
Keeping things together made sense then. The habit helped the family, and it earned him a place in it as the one they could count on. A boy who learns that his worth comes from keeping things together often becomes very good at it, because he gets plenty of practice and plenty of thanks.
Psychologists Dan McAdams and Kate McLean (2013) describe how people build a life story that explains who they are and how they came to be that way. A man’s story often includes the years when he learned what made him worth having around. A man whose story says “I’m the one who keeps things together” may find it hard to tell anyone that things are falling apart.
I know something of this from my own years in ministry. From the outside, I looked successful, and I kept up the role that was expected of me. Very few people around me knew how I was really doing, because the role didn’t leave room to say so.
I’ve written separately about why men stay silent, and about the competence tax in men, the cost of always being the capable one.
Why Telling a Mate Feels Like a Risk
When something goes badly, he keeps it to himself because telling a mate feels like being a burden. From the inside, keeping quiet feels like consideration. His mates have their own jobs and families, and he doesn’t want to add to what they are dealing with. When one of those mates had a bad patch last year, he was glad to know and rang him straight away. He has never asked whether his mates might feel the same way about him.
He may also worry about how his mates will see him. If he shows what he needs, or what he is really feeling, they might think less of him.
Michael Addis and James Mahalik (2003) reviewed research on why men often hold back from asking for help, mostly from professionals. They argued that context matters a great deal, including whether a problem seems central to how a man sees himself. The same pull can apply when the person he would tell is a mate. For a man who sees himself as the one who keeps things together, saying he is struggling can feel like giving up who he is.
For some men, a past experience adds to the habit. Perhaps a mate once repeated something, or laughed at the wrong moment, and he decided not to risk it again. If that is part of his story, it makes sense that he has been careful. That past experience is also a reason to choose the person and the moment with care the next time he tries.
What Changes When One Person Knows
When one mate knows what a man is dealing with at work, a few things change. He has someone to ring when the news at work is bad. The next time someone asks how he’s going, there is at least one person he doesn’t have to say “all good” to. The worry is still there, and he can talk it through with someone before the next meeting with his boss.
Nobody can predict how a mate will respond. Some mates have been through something similar and say so. Some go quiet or change the subject, because they don’t know what to say. Even when the conversation is short and awkward, the mate now knows about the worry at work, and either of you can bring it up again another time.
What Keeping Things Together Has Given You
Keeping things together built real qualities in you. You notice what other people need, often before they say it. Your mates trust you because you’ve earned it over years.
Those qualities are yours, and telling a mate how things really are takes none of them away. The mates you could tell are already in your life, at the footy club and at work, and some of them have known you for years. What you tell them is the part you can change. Saying more than “all good” takes practice, and the practice can start with one mate you trust.
The Male Identity Reconstruction Framework (MIRF®) assessment gives a private picture of five areas of your life, including how much is on you and who helps. The report starts with what is still working. Some men take it alongside the exercise below.
One Honest Sentence to One Mate
You choose when the conversation happens.
- Write down the last three times you said “all good”, or something like it, with the real answer beside each one.
Example: “Footy, Saturday. Real answer: two rough months at work, and I’m worried I’ll be laid off.”
- If you want to, answer one more question: when did you first become the one who kept things together? Write down your age, what was happening, and what you did.
Example: “I was about twelve. Dad worked away, Mum was flat out, and I looked after my younger brothers. Nobody asked me to. It was just what I did.”
- Choose a mate you trust, and a low-risk moment. Side by side often works best, such as at the footy or in the car. When you’re both looking at the road, nobody has to hold eye contact, and either of you can move on to the game if it gets too much.
Example: “Garry. We’ve been mates since high school. I’ll say it on the drive to the game on Saturday.”
- Prepare one honest sentence. Say it aloud once on your own, then say it to your mate. Keep it to one or two sentences about what is really going on. Saying it aloud first means the words have already left your mouth once, so they come more easily the second time.
Example: “Work’s been rough for two months. I’m worried I’ll be laid off, and I haven’t told anyone.”
- Afterwards, write down how your mate responded, compared with what you feared.
Example: “I thought he’d go quiet or change the subject. He said his brother went through the same thing last year and asked what the boss had actually said.”
What the Conversation Can Look Like
Here is how that can go. On Saturday you pick Garry up for the game. Ten minutes into the drive, you say the sentence you practised in the car on the way to work. Garry doesn’t say anything for a moment, then says, “That’s rough, mate” and asks who’s playing in the ruck. You talk about the game on the way home like you always do.
The conversation was short, and Garry may come back to it or he may not. For the first time in two months, a mate knows what’s going on at work.
Key Takeaways
A man can have plenty of mates and still feel alone when none of them knows he’s anxious about being laid off. Saying “all good” to every mate keeps the worry private, and he ends up dealing with the worry alone. One mate who knows gives him someone to ring when the news at work is bad.
Being honest about what he feels takes practice and courage, and honesty comes more easily with a mate he trusts. One prepared sentence, said side by side, is a practical place to start. Telling that mate takes nothing away from the qualities his friends already trust in him.
Questions Men Ask When Nobody Knows How They’re Going
What if my mate doesn’t know what to say?
Some mates won’t, and that’s all right. Telling him means one more person knows what you’re dealing with at work, even if he says very little at the time. Some mates find their words a day or two later, and some never raise it again. If the conversation is short, you can come back to it another time. Choosing a side-by-side moment, like a drive, makes a short conversation easier for both of you.
Is it normal to feel lonely even with a busy social life?
Yes. Many men with full calendars feel alone, because a busy social life and being known by someone can come apart. You can see people every day and still have nobody who knows what is hard for you right now. I’ve written more about loneliness and men.
Do I have to talk about my childhood to change this?
No. Noticing when the habit of keeping things together started can help you see it, and that is as far as this article goes. You can change what you tell one mate this week without going back over your childhood. If you want to look at your family history more closely, that is a separate piece of work, and a mentor or counsellor can help with it.
References
Addis, M. E., & Mahalik, J. R. (2003). Men, masculinity, and the contexts of help seeking. American Psychologist, 58(1), 5–14. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.58.1.5
McAdams, D. P., & McLean, K. C. (2013). Narrative identity. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 22(3), 233–238. https://doi.org/10.1177/0963721413475622
Weiss, R. S. (1973). Loneliness: The experience of emotional and social isolation. MIT Press.
Where to Go From Here
Mentoring Through the Maze® offers structured, non-clinical mentoring for men who seem fine to everyone and feel alone. Sessions run in person in Perth, or online on Google Meet or Teams. The MIRF® assessment is a private first look. It takes about 10 minutes, and the report starts with what is still working.
If you’d rather talk first, book a 30-minute introductory call.
About David Kernohan and Mentoring Through the Maze®
David Kernohan is the founder of Mentoring Through the Maze®, a Perth-based mentoring practice. Sessions run in person in Perth, or remotely on Google Meet or Teams. He offers structured, non-clinical mentoring for men going through grief, identity disruption, relationship breakdown and major life change. He brings more than thirty years of experience across mental health, legal and community sectors, together with his own lived experience of loss and change.
This article is general educational information. Mentoring Through the Maze® is a non-clinical mentoring service. It does not diagnose or treat mental illness, replace psychological therapy or medical care, or provide crisis support. If you are in crisis, call Lifeline on 13 11 14.