Skip to main content

Mentoring Through The Maze

Who Am I After a Big Life Change? Five Areas to Check, and Where to Start


Man in his late 40s talking with his brother-in-law over coffee about what comes next after a big life change

TL;DR

After a major life change, most men focus first on the practical things that need sorting. Starting there is often a necessity, and also sound judgement.

However, major changes often have a deeper impact than the practical side of daily life. A redundancy, a relationship breakdown, a serious illness or a death can all raise the question “Who am I now?” Many men set that question aside while they deal with the practical matters.

When the practical work is done, and a man still doesn’t feel like himself, this question often sits in the background. Checking five areas can help him see where in his life he is still carrying strain and where his strengths are. The five are who he is now, how he’s holding up, what he makes of it, how much is on him and who helps, and where he’s heading.

Why the Practical Problems Come First After a Big Change

The example running through this article is a redundancy. A man going through a separation, a serious illness or the death of someone close faces the same five areas. What he loses in each area depends on what happened. A separation can take away his role as a husband and the daily routine of family life. A serious illness can take away his energy and his ability to work. The redundancy example shows how to use each step of the check, so he can apply the same steps to his own situation.

After a redundancy, a man usually works first on what he can fix. He has to rework the budget and revise his CV and the job applications. Doing these things is sound judgement, because some of those problems really do have to come first. A man with a mortgage and kids at school can’t put the bills aside while he works out who he is.

The same pattern shows up after other big changes. After a separation, a man may need to find a lawyer and work out custody arrangements. After a death, there is the funeral to organise. This practical work is essential, and while it lasts, the questions about identity and who he is in this new life are pushed aside.

Fixing the practical problems also reassures the man that he is still capable and useful, at a time when much of his life has changed. For a man who has spent twenty years being good at his job, that reassurance matters.

Albert Bandura (1977) called a person’s belief in their own ability to get things done self-efficacy. He proposed that people are more likely to take on a task and keep at it when they believe they can handle it. He also proposed that repeated failure lowers this self-belief.

Some practical tasks build that belief. Redoing the budget or sorting out the super has a clear action and a clear result. He does the work, and the job is done. “Who am I now?” has no clear action at all.

Job applications work differently. He controls the effort, and other people control the result. Rewriting a CV after twenty years in one role is slow, frustrating work. Then the applications go out, and some get no reply at all. When he is passed over for roles he knows he could do, his confidence takes a hit. Each rejection is the kind of repeated failure Bandura described.

The question starts to form here.

Who am I now?

What is my usefulness and purpose?

Keeping Busy Without Knowing Where the Strain Is

Every weekday he’s still awake at 6.30, ready for work, with nowhere to drive to. At the shops, a neighbour asks what he’s doing with himself these days. He says “between things” and changes the subject. Out of habit, he still checks his phone for messages from the site.

The applications are out, and he waits. He has done everything he was supposed to do, and the outcome now rests with others. For a man who has always fixed problems by working harder, having no control is hard.

He may start to wonder whether he is past it, or whether the industry has moved on without him. Nothing has gone wrong with him.

Without knowing where the strain sits, a man often does one of two things. Some men keep busy. They find another job to do around the house, or apply for every role that comes up. Other men try to fix everything at once. They wear themselves out, and the part of life that is really struggling stays the same.

Either way, the question stays. For one man, the question settles once he is back at work. The pay comes in and the days have a shape again. Within a few weeks he feels like himself. Those unsettled weeks were an ordinary adjustment to a big change.

For another man, the new job pays the bills and still doesn’t feel like his. A man who ran his own site may now take orders on someone else’s. He does the work well, and he still doesn’t know how to answer when someone asks what he does. The money question is answered. The question of who he is now remains unanswered.

While he waits, the strain shows up at home. A man who has always been the one bringing in the money can feel out of place at home on a weekday. He may snap at the people at home over small things. He may lie awake worrying and feeling anxious about what will happen. Months can pass like this. All his effort goes into job applications, because applying feels like the only thing he can do.

Sorting out the money doesn’t fix everything a redundancy changes. A healthy bank balance won’t tell him who he is without the job, or what to do with his days.

Five Areas of Your Life a Big Change Can Reach

A big change can affect five areas of a man’s life at once.

Who He Is Now

For many men, work and marriage are part of the answer to “who am I?” When one of these roles changes, the habits that came with it often stay. A man made redundant after twenty years may still plan the day’s jobs in his head before he gets out of bed. He knows the job has gone. His routine hasn’t caught up.

After a separation, the old habits can be harder to let go of. He may still feel he ought to fix things at the old house, or step in when his ex-partner has a problem. Some of those things still matter, especially where children are involved. Others belong to a role he no longer holds, and they can keep him stuck. Part of the work in this area is telling one from the other. He is relearning who he is without those roles.

How He Is Holding Up Day to Day

This area covers the basics of an ordinary day. Is he sleeping most nights? Is he eating proper meals and getting out of the house?

When this area is still working, the basics carry on. He may be shaken by the change, and he still gets up each morning and goes to work.

When this area is under strain, the basics start to slip. He lies awake until 3 am, then sleeps through the morning. Days pass without him leaving the house.

Every other area gets harder from there. A man who has slept four hours has less patience for a job application, and less for the people at home. When this area is under strain, it is usually the place to start.

What He Makes of What Happened

Most big changes come with a story a man tells himself about why it happened. After a redundancy, a man who stayed through the hard years can come to see that loyalty as wasted. Another man decides he was never as good at the job as he thought.

After a separation, he may replay what he did wrong, or what he missed. After a death, he may go over what he could have done differently.

Some of the story may be true. Some of it comes from trying to make sense of and understand the impact of a loss. A harsh story can shape how he sees himself long after the event, and make the change harder to live with. One way to test the story is to compare it with the facts.

What He Is Responsible For and Who Helps

This area looks at two things. The first is what he is responsible for right now, like the bills and his family. The second is who helps him with those responsibilities.

The strain comes from carrying these responsibilities alone. Many men keep everything to themselves because being the provider is part of who they are. Asking for help can feel like proof the old role has gone. So offers of help get a short reply, and the people at home hear that everything is under control.

Some of his support also went with the job. The workmates he talked to every day were part of how he carried his responsibilities. He may not notice what they gave him until they are gone.

The help a man will take often looks practical. A partner who sits down with him to go over the bills helps carry the load, without either of them making a big deal of it. So does a mate who asks him to help on a weekend job.

A man with a lot to deal with can still cope if he has people helping him. A man with less to deal with can still struggle if he is doing it all alone.

Where His Life Is Heading

The last area is about the future he was counting on. Most men carry a plan for the next ten years, even if they never wrote it down. A redundancy can take the plan away along with the job.

Some men lose all sense of where life is going. Others find the change gives them a chance at something they had put off for years, like working for themselves or moving closer to family. Both can be true for the same man in the same month.

He doesn’t need a ten-year plan. A plan for the next three months is enough to give his days a purpose. The opposite mistake is rushing. A man who wants to get over the uncertainty can make a big decision too fast, like sinking his severance into a business before he’s tested the idea.

Why the Strain Usually Sits in One or Two Areas

When a man looks at all five areas, he usually finds that the change hasn’t hit them equally. One or two carry most of the strain. The others are still working, sometimes better than he expected.

In my work, most men want to start with the areas causing the most stress and strain. Their approach is “let’s fix this and move on.” The first step that works is often different. A man starts by remembering his strengths and his values. He also looks back at how he has handled hard times before.

Once he has those in mind, he deals better with the areas where he is carrying the most strain. The areas he is still working on often show him which strengths he still has.

Catherine Haslam and her colleagues (2021) reviewed research on how people get through big life changes. The evidence they reviewed suggests people often adjust better when they keep the groups that mattered to them, or join new ones. A study of retirees in England by the same research group found a similar pattern after leaving work (Steffens et al., 2016). For a man after a redundancy, those groups might be his old workmates or his industry contacts. His brother-in-law is one of them, and he is still in touch.

Knowing which areas are under strain also shows him what he can work on while he waits. A job application is aimed at the next job, and the answer can take months. That answer is out of his hands.

Much of the rest is up to him. He can get his sleep back on track, or ring an old workmate for a coffee. He can test the story he tells about the redundancy against the facts. Each of those gives him progress he can see within a week, whatever the applications bring.

A Five-Area Check for Who You Are After a Big Change

The check has no time limit.

  1. Write one sentence for each area. Say how the area is now. A few words is enough. Then mark it “under strain” or “still working”.

Who you are now: “I still wake up planning the day on site, and there’s no site to go to.” Under strain.

How you’re holding up day to day: “I’m sleeping all right most nights, and I get up and walk the dog.” Still working.

What you make of what happened: “I gave them twenty years, and it ended in a fifteen-minute meeting.” Under strain.

How much is on you, and who helps: “Money’s tight for six months. My brother-in-law keeps sending me job leads.” Still working.

Where your life is heading: “I’ve wanted to work for myself for years, and now I could look at it properly.” Still working.

  1. Write down one hard time you’ve got through before. Note what you did that got you through it. Then write one thing that still matters to you, whatever has changed.
  1. Choose the area under the most strain. If two are close, pick the one that comes to mind first when you wake up. If sleep or routine is under strain, start there. Everything else is harder when you are tired and your days have no structure.

Example: “Who I am now. Most of my habits still belong to a job I don’t have.”

  1. Name one thing from a still-working area that can help with it. Then name one step you will take this week.
  1. Write down the day you’ll do it.

Example: “My brother-in-law knows the industry. I’ll ask him for a coffee on Thursday and talk about what else I could do with what I know.”

  1. Write one line about how it went. Once you’ve taken the step, note what happened. Come back to the check in a few weeks and see which marks have changed.

If your sleep or mood has stayed low for weeks, see your GP first. The same goes if the distress feels like more than you can carry. A psychologist may suit you better for now, and mentoring can come later. If you’re in crisis, call Lifeline on 13 11 14.

What the MIRF® Assessment Adds to the Five-Area Check

The five areas in the check are the same five areas the Male Identity Reconstruction Framework (MIRF®) assessment looks at. The assessment asks a set of questions about each one. A private report then sets out which areas look most strained and which still look like they are working.

Some men are happy to do the check themselves and go from there. Others want a more detailed picture, in a report they can come back to or bring to a mentoring session. The MIRF® assessment is for the second group. The report starts with what is still working, so the next step builds on what is already there.

The Next Time Someone Asks

The applications may still be out, and no replies may have come. You may still not feel like yourself. You now have a clearer idea why, and which of the five areas carry the strain.

You also know what you have to work with. You’ve got through hard times before, and you know what you did then. The man who still wakes at 6.30 and walks the dog is still you. So is the man your brother-in-law keeps sending leads to.

The replies are out of your hands. The step you’ve chosen for this week is yours, and it’s on your calendar. Next time someone asks what you’re doing, you can say more than “between things”.

Questions Men Ask After a Big Life Change

How do I adjust to what has happened?

Adjusting usually starts with remembering what has got you through hard times before. From there, you can take on the area under the most strain, with help from an area that still works. For one man, that means talking to someone in his old industry about what else he could do with what he knows. For another, it means getting his sleep back before anything else. Many men adjust one step at a time, and each step gives them something to build on.

How long does it take to feel like yourself after a big life change?

There is no set time, and it differs a lot from man to man and change to change. Some of the unsettled feeling is ordinary adjustment that eases with time. If you check the five areas every few weeks, you can see which ones are moving and which ones are stuck. If your sleep or mood stays low for weeks and doesn’t lift, see your GP.

What if all five areas feel under strain?

Some men mark every area as under strain at first, especially soon after the change. Look again at each one and ask what still works in it, however small. If everything still feels hard, start with how you’re holding up day to day, because sleep and routine make the other areas easier to work on.

Is feeling lost after a redundancy normal?

Yes. Many men feel lost after a redundancy, especially after years in one trade or one company. Losing the job takes away part of the answer to “who am I?”, as well as the income. I’ve written separately about job loss and grief, for men whose redundancy still feels like a loss. I’ve also written about men feeling lost in life and about rebuilding identity after loss.

Where to Go From Here

The five-area check is enough to start. If you want a fuller picture, the MIRF® assessment covers the same five areas in about 10 minutes.

If you’d rather talk it through first, book a 30-minute introductory call. Sessions run in person in Perth, or online on Google Meet or Teams.

References

Bandura, A. (1977). Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. Psychological Review, 84(2), 191–215. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.84.2.191

Haslam, C., Haslam, S. A., Jetten, J., Cruwys, T., & Steffens, N. K. (2021). Life change, social identity, and health. Annual Review of Psychology, 72, 635–661. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-psych-060120-111721

Steffens, N. K., Cruwys, T., Haslam, C., Jetten, J., & Haslam, S. A. (2016). Social group memberships in retirement are associated with reduced risk of premature death: Evidence from a longitudinal cohort study. BMJ Open, 6(2), e010164. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2015-010164

About David Kernohan and Mentoring Through the Maze®

David Kernohan is the founder of Mentoring Through the Maze®, a Perth-based mentoring practice. He offers structured, non-clinical mentoring for men going through grief, identity disruption, relationship breakdown and major life change. He brings more than thirty years of experience across mental health, legal and community sectors, together with his own lived experience of loss and change.

This article is general educational information. Mentoring Through the Maze® is a non-clinical mentoring service. The service does not diagnose or treat mental illness, replace psychological therapy or medical care, or provide crisis support. If you are in crisis, call Lifeline on 13 11 14.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts